Source (http://www.jsonline.com/news/milwaukee/duped-by-innocence-project-milwaukee-man-now-free-b99386015z1-281852841.html)
QuoteThe first time I wrote about Alstory Simon, then a Milwaukee north sider, was in 1999, right after he confessed to a double murder in Chicago.
Simon's shocking admission — not to police but to an investigator working for Northwestern University's Innocence Project — led to the release and pardon of a man on death row for the crime, and ultimately to the death penalty being abolished in Illinois.
Two years later, I wrote about Simon again. This time he had reached out to me from prison to say the confession and subsequent guilty plea were involuntary. He insisted he was innocent, as do most inmates who send letters to reporters from prison.
My column was not sympathetic. His confession was right there on videotape for everyone to see, including the detail that he had "busted off about six rounds."
Last week, Simon walked out of prison a free man after Cook County State's Attorney Anita Alvarez announced that her office, after a yearlong investigation, was vacating the charges against him and ending his 37-year sentence.
The investigation by the Innocence Project, she said, "involved a series of alarming tactics that were not only coercive and absolutely unacceptable by law enforcement standards, they were potentially in violation of Mr. Simon's constitutionally protected rights."
The truth took 15 years to come out. That's 15 years that Simon, now 64, spent behind bars.
"Believe me, it is mentally painful to walk around every day, locked up for something that you know you didn't do," Simon told Shawn Rech, whose film about the case, "A Murder in the Park" now has an ending. It premieres at a film festival in New York on Nov. 17.
Simon, who moved to Milwaukee from Chicago in the 1980s to find work, is not granting interviews, his attorney, Terry Ekl, told me. But Ekl echoed Alvarez's criticism of former Northwestern journalism professor David Protess, who led the Innocence Project, and the investigator on the team, Paul Ciolino.
"In my opinion, Northwestern, Protess and Ciolino framed Simon so that they could secure the release of (Anthony) Porter and make him into the poster boy for the anti-death penalty movement," he said.
Identified by several eye witnesses, Porter was sentenced to death for the fatal shooting of Jerry Hillard and Marilyn Green at a south side Chicago park in 1982. He was just two days from a lethal chemical injection when he was freed in February 1999 following Simon's confession.
Then-Gov. George Ryan imposed a moratorium on the death penalty in 2000, and Illinois abolished capital punishment in 2011.
But that neat and clean narrative unraveled with the discovery of how the confession by Simon was obtained. Protess discovered that Green's mother had mentioned Simon was with Green and Hillard at the park the day of the murders, so Protess went after Simon in an effort to clear Porter.
Protess and two of his journalism students came to Simon's home in the 200 block of E. Wright St. in Milwaukee and told him they were working on a book about unsolved murders. According to Simon, Protess told him, "We know you did it."
Then Simon received a visit from Ciolino and another man. They had guns and badges and claimed to be Chicago police officers. They said they knew he had killed Green and Hillard, so he better confess if he hoped to avoid the death penalty.
They showed him a video of his ex-wife, Inez Jackson, implicating him for the crime — a claim she recanted on her death bed in 2005 — and another video of a supposed witness to the crime who turned out to be an actor.
They coached Simon through a videotaped confession, promising him a light sentence and money from book and movie deals on the case. Simon, admittedly on a three-day crack cocaine bender, struggled to understand what was going on.
Perhaps worst of all, they hooked up Simon with a free lawyer to represent him, Jack Rimland, without telling him that Rimland was a friend of Ciolino and Protess and in on their plan to free Porter.
At Rimland's urging, Simon pleaded guilty to the crime and even offered what sounded like a sincere apology to Green's family in court. As added leverage to make him cooperate, Rimland had told Simon he was suspected in a Milwaukee murder, though nothing ever came of it.
"Bob told me to get rid of this attorney...I should have listened to him," Simon says in the film, referring to Bob Braun, a West Allis man best known around here for protesting against abortion, same-sex marriage, pornography and other issues. The two men are friends.
Braun said he never doubted Simon's innocence. The two men wrote back and forth regularly during Simon's incarceration, and Braun visited him there twice. After 15 years in prison, Simon told Braun the most noticeable change is that everyone carries a phone, and there are no more pay phones.
When his abuses came to light, Protess was suspended by Northwestern and has since retired from there. He isn't talking, but he is now president of the Chicago Innocence Project which investigates wrongful convictions. Ciolino put out a statement saying Simon also had confessed to a Milwaukee TV reporter, his lawyer and others. "You explain that," he said.
We know now that the explanation was that Simon was snared in a trap set by people who wanted to end the death penalty, no matter what the cost. Once they convinced Simon it was for his own good, he was all in.
And now, finally, he's out and back in Chicago. Simon enjoyed a lobster dinner on his first day of freedom. Ekl said he doesn't think Simon has family still in Milwaukee, and is not planning to return here. Too many painful memories.
Simon's mother died while he was in prison. He told the filmmaker he's eager to reconnect with his daughter and see his grandchild for the first time.
"I thank God," he said, "that he shined down on me."
This is not a BBE I ever wanted to see, but considering all the fucked up shit they did in this case, basically everything they've complained about when it came to prosecutors, no one else can come close to taking that title.
I don't get it; why does this make The Innocence Project BBE?
Quote from: MrBogosity on November 12, 2014, 07:11:49 AM
I don't get it; why does this make The Innocence Project BBE?
You don't have a section for pure scumbaggery, but basically, they did everything they go after prosecutors for to get an innocent man to admit to a crime he didn't do in order to save their own client. They went to ridiculous lengths to do it too, including hiring an actor to claim himself a witness to the murder. Not only that, but the defense lawyer they hooked him up with was in on the scheme the entire time. To make matters worse, the person was high on crack at the time so he was in a completely vulnerable state of mind.
All of this MORE than makes it plain as day that the Innocence Project, who was responsible for ALL of what happened to Alstory Simon, makes them more than deserving of SOMETHING. Whether it's biggest bogon emitter, idiot extraordinaire, or just being called complete and total scumbags makes no difference.
Quote from: D on November 12, 2014, 08:28:23 AM
You don't have a section for pure scumbaggery, but basically, they did everything they go after prosecutors for to get an innocent man to admit to a crime he didn't do in order to save their own client. They went to ridiculous lengths to do it too, including hiring an actor to claim himself a witness to the murder. Not only that, but the defense lawyer they hooked him up with was in on the scheme the entire time. To make matters worse, the person was high on crack at the time so he was in a completely vulnerable state of mind.
All of this MORE than makes it plain as day that the Innocence Project, who was responsible for ALL of what happened to Alstory Simon, makes them more than deserving of SOMETHING. Whether it's biggest bogon emitter, idiot extraordinaire, or just being called complete and total scumbags makes no difference.
Has that defense attorney died as well? If not, he's in a world of trouble. Law societies do NOT take deliberately shafting your own client well at all. That's not even counting the law suit the victim has against the whole lot of them.
So much of this doesn't smell right. If it happened the way it did, there should be disbarments all round. Rimland at least should be out on his ass.
Is the only information about all this from the film?